Guide to NYC Real Estate Investment

New to NYC Real Estate Investment? Defining your goals before you start helps to determine a successful investment property strategy. There are many good reasons for buying investment property in NYC, for example:

  • Equity growth and capital appreciation, because the real estate market is lower risk than many other markets which are intended to produce growth.
  • Wealth storage, especially for overseas investors who want a stable, productive, and appreciating asset in a lower risk market.
  • Getting the maximum tax benefits which will automatically lead to maximizing both yield and underlying price appreciation.
  • Ease of leveraging the investment to deliver the most profit.
  • A hedge against inflation because rental income produces not only an acceptable yield, but it can be raised at frequent, predetermined or agreed times (e.g. annually or when a new lease is signed.)
  • Deliver lifestyle benefits and emotional wellbeing because the asset is so visible, usable, and income-generating. And in the future, should it be part of the underlying strategy, it may be lived in and enjoyed by the owner or their family.
  • Provide a well-proven market model for a family member to learn how to manage their own business enterprise before, say, getting involved in and then taking over the reins of the family's primary business.

There are many sound reasons to choose either residential or commercial real estate in New York. If residential, the choices are broad. Where should the investment property, or properties, be located? What type of investment properties should be chosen? Options, driven by strategy and goals, include luxury condos, lower-priced condos, townhomes, single family homes, and multi-family homes such as a duplex, triplex or quadplex.


The agents of Manhattan Miami Real Estate have been  serving buyers and sellers for over 15 years. We have amassed significant knowledge of the Manhattan and Miami real estate markets that we constantly share with our clients who appreciate our honesty and integrity. 


We have put together an in-depth Step-by-Step Guide when looking for a Miami or NYC Real Estate Investment


  1. Have an Effective Investment Strategy
  2. Where to Invest in Real Estate
  3. Choose a Good Location
  4. Choose the Right Property Type
  5. Choose the Right Building
  6. The Cost Components of a Real Estate Investment
  7. The Other Side of the Coin
  8. What is a 1031 Tax Deferred Exchange?
  9. Getting the Return on Your Investment
  10. Property Management for Investors
  11. Final Remarks


Successful real estate investing rests squarely on building a strategy based on business goals which help to choose the best investment property's location and type. Understanding the investment property market takes time to learn and understand, so the fourth part of a successful strategy (besides goal, location, and type) is to make the best use of the best advice available. We discuss investment goals in "A Proven Strategy for Buying Your First Rental Property" and "Don't Chase Yield when Buying an Investment Property." Successful investors continually ask themselves, "Is this the best advice I can get, and am I making the best use of that advice?

Answering that question is what this article is all about.

Comparable Properties


Real estate is global. Many factors, from global to local, affect current prices, future capital value, and current rental income. As well as global and regional factors to consider, each country has its own income, real estate, and capital gains tax regulations. They also have their own purchase, financing,  and sales costs. These costs have a direct effect on cap rate, net cash flow, leverage, and future profits.

Within each country there are cities. Each city has benefits and disadvantages for the real estate investor (both domestic and overseas investors.) By taking regional and national factors into account, and then drilling down to the city level, investors are more able to make wise decisions and the best choices, so they maximize the results that deliver on the seven reasons listed above.

Neighborhood Overview to NYC Real Estate Investors

How to Invest in Real Estate in Manhattan or Miami


The right location is critical to ultimate success. In our article "An Analysis of the Best Cities to Invest in Rental Properties in 2019" you will see a detailed analysis of the subject. In summary, the International Monetary Fund studied 57 economies and divided them into three categories as far as real estate investment is concerned. We linked this study to UBS Wealth Management's most recent report on 20 individual cities. It is clear that some of the world's cities, such as Hong Kong, Toronto, and London are in what UBS calls "bubble-risk" territory. Others are listed as over-valued, fairly-valued, and undervalued.

Our focus as realtors is on New York City, particularly Manhattan and its neighborhoods. We also, however, have information on Downtown Miami as well as general tips for investing in Miami luxury real estate.

When buying investment property in New York, location matters. The right location for the investment property plus choosing the right property itself will deliver on all seven reasons listed above. Each city has neighborhoods, and those neighborhoods will deliver price appreciation to a larger or smaller extent. Each neighborhood will also appeal to specific rental market types. Such types include, for example:

  • Professionals who prefer to rent rather than own a property close to their place of business, and which also meets their social and family lifestyle goals.
  • Wealthy individuals who want an occasional pied-à-terre for business visits or vacation property for longer occupancy, so their family can make the most of the building's and area's social, dining, and shopping amenities.
  • People with young families who prefer to, or must, rent the right home in the right location.
  • Students who attend the local college, university, or private school or academy.
  • Each of these four rental-market examples will help the investor to determine which location to choose and which property type to choose. All of these markets tend to see high occupancy rates at high rental prices. They, therefore, generate high yield, good cash flow, and good property price appreciation.


Property location


Different property types attract different types of tenants. When investors choose the right type of real estate to buy, they should look closely and choose the right building for the types of tenants they want to attract. There are several types of good rental property.

Multi family homes make excellent rental properties. A multi-family property is, basically, a building in which there are more than one self-contained homes. The building may be a duplex (two homes,) a triplex (three homes,) a quadplex or fourplex (four homes,) or an apartment building (condo or cooperative development.)

There are several advantages to investing in a multifamily home. Choosing a property which specifically meets an investor's immediate and longer-term goals is straightforward. Many renters almost automatically choose a multi-family unit, so the market is strong. They go down this route because they are the types of property most available, so it is easy for them to choose the specific property that is right for them. They will find neighbors "just like them" so social and family life will be enjoyable.

The building will have a professional property manager to both maintain the amenities, and to handle problems.

Multifamily investment properties maximize or, at the minimum, smooth yield rates. If a single-family investment property is empty for a month, the yield is reduced by 100%. If one unit of a fourplex is unoccupied for a month, the overall yield is reduced by only 25%.

If a family member lives in one unit and is the property manager for the others - to learn the basics of managing and running a business - then the income from the other units pays for, or contributes to, the costs of the family member's home and generates profit to invest in the next property purchase. Those two factors are an incentive to ensure the rental property business is successful.




Once investors choose the property's location and the property type, the next decision is about choosing the right building. There are two sides to this decision; the investor's side and the tenant's side. Get them both right, and the result is investment success.

The Investor's Side

Again, the decisions incorporate the underlying goals. In simple, practical terms the decisions are based on such things as:

  • Do the rules and regs enable acceptable rental and leasing rates? A cooperative can have regulations that prevent leasing the unit for a minimum period. Coops also demand that potential tenants are interviewed and approved.
  • Are there any city or community regs that may limit how much rent can be charged or how many (or how few) days in a year the property may house each tenant?
  • How soon will the property be ready to rent? Is it worth buying an unfinished property at an excellent price, to maximize future price appreciation and miss out on initial rental income or should you buy an occupant-ready property to maximize immediate yield and offset the cost of purchase, etc?
  • If the property is complete, what is its condition? A professional inspection by a qualified home inspector, preferably working to ASHI Standards (American Society of Home Inspectors) to make sure everything that should be inspected is inspected. Safety or functionality problems should be addressed in the purchase agreement and handled prior to closing.

The Tenant's Side

Tenants tend to choose a home based on five criteria. They boil down to prestige, privacy, space, view, and convenience. "The PPSVC of renting." These factors are not in any order of importance since some tenants prize one or more over the others. Let us discuss them:

  • Prestige can be very important. A wealthy tenant looking for an occasional city unit, because they prefer a home to a hotel suite, may put the prestige of the property and its location high on their list. A student or professional family may not.
  • Privacy is often important to many people. A celebrity or a family with young children may look for privacy.
  • Space matters to tenants with children or to someone who needs a home office, but less so to a student or single tenant who just wants to be close to their college or the office.
  • Views matter to many people. Buying a multifamily unit that is high enough to give a feeling of space when looking out of the windows often carries a price premium over a unit that is on a lower floor with a view of a brick wall. A view of Central Park, for example, demands a high purchase price, generates a higher yield and delivers a high selling price when it is time to liquidate the profits.

A less impressive view may not deliver a high enough yield to cover the purchase cost premium, but by leveraging the investment that issue is mitigated. Units with better views, especially if there is little to choose in rent payments, will always see higher occupancy rates than units with poor views.

  • Convenience matters to many tenants. They want to be close to the office, college, a play area if they have children, good transportation, etc. Convenience is a powerful motivator and often delivers higher occupancy rates for the landlord.

When both the owner's and the tenant's sides get taken into account, it is easier to choose the right building, and then to maximize cash flow and profit.



Wise investors understand the costs of both buying real estate in NYC and owning it afterward. Cost components fall into three main categories:

  • Cost of acquisition
  • Operating Costs
  • Cost of Sale

Acquisition costs include the price paid for the property plus purchase of items needed to rent it out. In Manhattan and Miami, kitchen appliances are usually included in the purchase. In Manhattan flooring in a new apartment will be but in Miami, it may not be. These comments on the lower purchase prices for Miami apartments will interest investors for whom initial costs are a priority.

Buyers pay for their inspections, title insurance, title agent fees, and closing attorney fees, plus prorated costs such as taxes or management fees the seller has prepaid. Operating costs include such items as property management fees, insurance, taxes, utilities, and mortgage costs, etc. These should be covered by occupying tenants' rents. Owners may also be responsible for their own marketing costs when looking for tenants.

When owners sell their investment property they will pay the broker's fees to market the property and to find a ready, willing, and able buyer. They may also hire their own legal advisor, as well as being responsible for any repairs to make the property safe and functional.

NYC Real Estate Investors


While there are costs, there are also valuable tax benefits that investors use to minimize their costs. It pays investors to understand property tax rules and regulations because the purchase and management of the property is a business transaction, so all valid costs are tax deductible.

The IRS rules are very pro-investor unlike in many countries. As well as direct costs of purchase and ownership being tax deductible, an owner can depreciate the property's value over 27.5 years. So, even though the property gains in market value, it can still be depreciated for tax purposes. When it is time to sell, by using a 1031 Exchange (see below) the potential tax can be deferred as long as the sales proceeds are invested in another "like-kind" item. "Like-kind" does not, for tax purposes, necessarily mean another piece of real estate.

New York city offers tax abatement opportunities, and Florida does not have a state income tax. Foreign investors should seek advice on establishing a corporate entity and other tax matters, so they avoid or minimize US tax liability.

For US business entities, if the rental business's taxable income is less than $315,000 (and it is not a C Corporation) then a "pass-through" deduction equal to 20% of the qualifying business income may be deducted from the tax bill. US tax laws are very pro-business, and the recent tax law changes for investors and homeowners deserve special attention.


The 1031 Tax Deferred Exchange (named for Section 1031 of the US Internal Revenue Code) enables an investor to sell a property and to use all the sale proceeds to buy one or more "like-kind" properties of equal or greater value, within an approved timescale, without paying any capital gains tax on the property being sold. The tax is deferred until there is a final liquidation without further investment.

The 1031 rule, therefore, is an excellent way of maximizing return on investment because all the profit can be used to buy the next property (or properties) without passing any of the profit to the government.

Investors can use this benefit to consolidate or diversify current investments, make the most of an emerging market, make better returns elsewhere, or reset the depreciation clock. Brownstones held in New York can be "exchanged" for a Miami luxury condo, for example. Vacant land or a commercial building held in Miami can be "exchanged" for other investment real estate in New York. The options are many, the rules governing exchanges are tight, and the transactions must be handled by an approved intermediary.

By relying on sound advice from the real estate agent or property manager, investors can maximize their returns. This brings us to the next section.

"Capital Gains Tax on Real Estate"


Obviously, there are three major components to getting the biggest return on your investment. The first is the price you pay. Considering the eventual resale during the purchase process is a sign of a successful investor. The article in the link focuses on Miami, but the principles discussed are components of any investment property purchase/resale thought process.

The costs of, and the income from, ownership are critically important to the ultimate return. A question our clients often ask is how to get the most bang for their buck – besides negotiating a great purchase price on the right property in the right location. A powerful way to ensure that is to leverage the purchase.

Two Approaches to Leverage

The first, and obvious, is to take out a mortgage loan on the property. Foreign investors learn there are well-established and willing American lenders when looking for real estate loans. Domestic investors often put down 20% and borrow the rest. Overseas investors often make a 50% down payment.

The down payment may come from stock market profit-taking, or the sale of an existing property to make the most of price appreciation and the 1031 Exchange benefits. The cost of amortization is tax deductible, of course, and the tenant is there to cover the loan costs via their rent.

The second most common way is to use the equity in a current property to use as the down payment. The two ways of doing this are to take out a mortgage loan using the property's equity for security. The second way is to use a home equity line of credit (HELOC.) The main difference is that the line of credit can be used for anything and interest is only paid on credit used. It, therefore, enables a more subtle approach to look for the right investment property, and to cover the purchase costs and those of any renovation, etc.

An obvious benefit of financing the purchase is that price appreciation of the property is being funded by the down payment and the rental income. A $600,000 down payment on a $3 million property which sees a price appreciation of 5% ($150,000) means the appreciation represents a 25% return on the down payment amount.

Financing for accredited investors makes good business sense.

Using the right property manager will maximize occupancy because the management company will market the property to potential tenants, vet them, and manage the rental contract while it is active. The decision to contract out that activity often produces better tenants and higher occupancy rates. Both result in a higher yield.

The third element of getting the right return is to put the sale in the hands of a skilled and successful real estate agent who will market it correctly. The agent will help to negotiate the best price the market will bear, on the best terms for the current owner, and within the owner's preferred timescale.

Put those three elements together, including a 1031 Exchange if appropriate, and the property will generate the highest return on the investment. That's what making the best real estate investment decision is all about.



Managing investment properties effectively takes time, skill, and experience. There are two kinds of property management, "light property management" and "full property management." Light property management is a route many clients take because it takes care of the initial, critical elements, and can begin as soon as the chosen investment property is under contract.

Light Property Management

This service manages all the steps beginning with finding the right tenant. The investment property is marketed to prospective tenants, the tenant is screened, the lease prepared, applications to condo boards are supported, and any necessary repairs, etc. are arranged. Light property management excludes handling tenant or landlord monies but does include terminating and renewing leases.

Full Property Management

This service includes handling rents and paying bills, etc. with full accounting services and financial reporting. It also takes care of tenant evictions should that ever be necessary.

Manhattan Miami Property Management Services

Property Management for Investors


Buying and owning investment properties is a profitable business model, and a well-proven way to build and protect wealth. By leveraging investments, taking advantage of all the potential tax allowances and deferments, and installing the right tenants maximizes yield and price appreciation. NYC real estate investment is always a solid bet.

Choosing an experienced property management company to market the investment property, select tenants, and arrange landlord-protective lease documents is another sensible element of becoming a successful investment property owner. Investment properties prove themselves to be a solid way to achieve many goals.

Contact us today and learn how to invest in real estate in Manhattan or Miami.

Investment Properties

Invest In Miami



Do I need a Realtor?