City officials are again aiming to bring New York City property tax reform to Albany, and they still have no bill. At a joint City Council hearing on Tuesday, November 17, a Department of Finance official said the agency is working with City Hall on reform and hopes to have legislation for the state legislative session that opens in January. Pressed by Deputy Speaker Nantasha Williams, the department said: "We do not yet have a bill. We are working on developing a bill."
Manhattan co-ops and condos are valued for property tax using rental comparables rather than sale prices, and the city's 2021 reform commission proposed changing that. This guide explains how your tax is set today, what the 2021 reform blueprint proposed, and what to check now. The section on current taxation describes existing rules. The reform proposals are recommendations, and at the November 17 hearing officials said they did not yet have a bill. For more on the city, see our Manhattan insights.
At a glance
- At the November 17 hearing, the Department of Finance said it has no property tax reform bill yet and hopes to have legislation for the January session in Albany. The Real Deal and The East New York Times both reported the exchange.
- State law requires the city to value co-op and condo buildings as if they were rental buildings, using the income and expenses of comparable rentals, not the prices units sell for.
- Co-ops and condos are in tax class 2, which has a 45% assessment ratio. For buildings with 10 or fewer units, assessed value increases are capped at 8% a year and 30% over five years, so assessed value can differ from 45% of the city's market value.
- The 2021 Advisory Commission on Property Tax Reform proposed valuing co-ops and condos on sales, assessing at full market value with lower rates, phasing changes in over five years and ending the co-op and condo abatement.
- The structural reforms discussed here would require state legislation. Until a bill is published, any estimate for a specific apartment rests on assumptions.
What Happened at the Hearing
The joint hearing of the Council's Committee on Housing and Buildings and its Committee on Finance included discussion of the tax lien sale the city plans to bring back in 2027. Property tax reform came up when council members asked what the city would do about unequal tax burdens. The East New York Times reported that a department official said the agency is working with City Hall and hopes to have legislation for the upcoming session.
The Real Deal reported that Jeffrey Shear, the department's first deputy commissioner, said the agency is working on a reform bill it expects to send to Albany lawmakers before the next legislative session, and called it premature to discuss possible sponsors. Williams was not persuaded. "I do not believe you all are actually actively working towards property tax reform," she said, and told officials that advocacy in Albany has to start early. According to The East New York Times, she also said the state has repeatedly said it is waiting for the city to send something up.
The timetable has already moved once. The Real Deal reported that in February the city's budget director told the Council a proposal would be ready within weeks, and that by June he had pushed it to the next state legislative session.
The reform discussion has run for years. A city commission published its final recommendations in December 2021, and a lawsuit over the system was allowed to go forward in 2024. The November hearing put the city's timetable under fresh scrutiny less than two months before the session opens.
How Manhattan Co-ops and Condos Are Taxed Today
The Department of Finance does not use sale prices to value co-op and condo apartments. State law requires it to value residential co-op and condo buildings as if they were rental apartment buildings, which means it looks at the income and expenses of rental buildings with similar characteristics. Comparables are chosen by number of units, size, age, distance and number of stories, and the department adjusts them for differences.
That figure is the department's market value. Tax class 2, which includes co-ops, condos and rental apartment buildings, has a 45% assessment ratio. For buildings with 10 or fewer units (classes 2a, 2b and 2c), state law limits increases in assessed value to 8% a year and 30% over five years. Larger buildings have increases phased in through transitional assessed values. Tax rates are applied to the taxable assessed value, after exemptions, and abatements then reduce the bill.
The Citizens Budget Commission, a nonpartisan budget watchdog, has listed among the system's main problems that the department's market values often do not reflect prices in arm's-length sales. For a high-value unit, the department's market value and the price you paid can be far apart.
Values still move each year. In the tentative roll for fiscal year 2027, published in January, the department put the total market value of class 2 at $422.4 billion, up 6.9%. Co-op market values rose 4.6% and condo market values 4.0%. Our guide to NYC and Miami real estate taxes covers rates, transfer taxes and how the costs compare with Miami.
What the 2021 Blueprint Proposed
The New York City Advisory Commission on Property Tax Reform, appointed in May 2018, released a detailed reform blueprint in its final report on December 29, 2021. It is a set of recommendations, not the bill the department described, and any bill may differ from it. For co-op and condo owners, these were its central proposals:
- One residential class. One- to three-family homes, co-ops, condos and rental buildings of four to 10 units would share a new residential class.
- Sales-based values. Every property in that class would be valued with a sales-based method, replacing the rental-comparable approach for co-ops and condos.
- Full market value. Fractional assessment would end for all property types. Each property would be assessed at its full market value, and the commission said the tax rate needed to raise the same revenue would fall.
- No caps, a five-year phase-in. The current caps on assessed value growth would end for the new class. Changes in market value would be phased in over five years at 20% a year.
- A homestead exemption, and no abatement. A partial exemption would go to primary-resident owners with incomes up to $500,000, phasing out above $375,000. The co-op and condo abatement would be eliminated.
- Transfers during the transition. For properties in the new residential class, the new system would phase in over five years, and a property that changed hands during that period would be fully phased in the fiscal year after the transfer.
In testimony to the Council in November 2022, the Citizens Budget Commission estimated that the new class would have a total market value of about $1.5 trillion, roughly 40% above its valuation at the time. That estimate is from 2022 and describes the class as a whole, not any single building.
What Sales-Based Valuation Could Mean for Manhattan Owners
The proposals would affect apartments differently. A sales-based value would track what similar units sell for, which is a different number from the rental-based value the department uses now. The bigger the gap between the two for a given apartment, the more a move to sales-based values could matter, before rates and any phase-in are applied.
Three of the 2021 proposals bear on second-home owners and buyers of high-value units. The 2021 homestead exemption was limited to primary-resident owners. The plan would have ended the co-op and condo abatement. Under the plan, a property bought during the five-year transition would have been fully phased into the new system the fiscal year after the purchase. None of this is law, and a 2027 bill could keep, change or drop any of it.
Reform is also separate from the pied-a-terre surcharge on high-value second homes, which has its own rules and valuation base. Our analysis of the pied-a-terre tax and Manhattan luxury real estate covers that surcharge.
The Lawsuit Behind the Pressure
A group called Tax Equity Now New York has challenged the system in court. On March 19, 2024, New York's Court of Appeals held that its complaint stated claims against the city under section 305(2) of the Real Property Tax Law and the federal Fair Housing Act, and let those claims proceed. The court dismissed the claims against the state and the group's other claims against the city. The decision allowed the case to continue. It did not change anyone's tax bill.
What Owners and Buyers Can Do Now
Before a bill is published, any modeling can only explore hypothetical reforms. You can still know your own numbers before Albany takes this up. These are the steps we would take.
- Pull your Notice of Property Value. Find the department's market value, assessed value and tax class for your unit or building on the city's property portal, and read it next to your latest tax bill.
- Compare like with like. For a condo unit, set the department's market value for that unit beside your purchase price or recent comparable sales. In a co-op, the department's valuation covers the whole building, so any sales-based comparison needs an estimate for the same building, not one apartment's price. Differences in dates and property characteristics also affect the gap, and the gap alone does not predict a change in your tax bill.
- Ask the managing agent about exemptions and abatements. Find out whether your unit receives the co-op and condo abatement or any other benefit, and what it is worth on your bill. In a co-op, ask how the building's tax is passed through in maintenance.
- Look at more than one tax scenario. If you are buying, an adviser can compare current carrying costs with hypothetical higher and lower tax bills, with the assumptions stated. Any transfer-related consequences would depend on the law that is finally enacted.
- Watch January. The state legislative session opens in January. An introduced bill would give a basis for analysis, although apartment-level estimates could also need rates, valuation data and implementation details.
- Bring in your tax adviser. An accountant or tax attorney can assess how current rules, and any changes that are enacted, apply to your circumstances. This guide is general information, not tax advice.
Buying in Manhattan, or holding an apartment and wondering what reform could mean for your carrying costs? We can help you review a building's published tax information and current carrying costs, and your tax adviser can address future liability. Message us on WhatsApp for a private, no-pressure conversation.
FAQ
Is NYC property tax reform happening in 2027?
That is uncertain. At a City Council hearing on November 17, 2026, the Department of Finance said it does not have a bill and is working on one it hopes to have for the January session in Albany. The structural reforms discussed here would require state legislation.
How are Manhattan condos and co-ops valued for property tax?
State law requires the Department of Finance to value co-op and condo buildings as if they were rental buildings, using income and expense data from comparable rentals. Tax class 2 has a 45% assessment ratio. For buildings with 10 or fewer units, assessed value increases are capped at 8% a year and 30% over five years, so assessed value can differ from 45% of market value.
What did the 2021 property tax reform commission recommend?
It recommended a new residential class of one- to three-family homes, co-ops, condos and four- to 10-unit rentals, valued on sales and assessed at full market value. It also proposed a five-year phase-in of value changes, a homestead exemption for primary-resident owners with incomes up to $500,000, and an end to the co-op and condo abatement. These are recommendations, not law.
Would property tax reform raise taxes on Manhattan condos?
That remains uncertain, although estimates can be made under clearly stated assumptions. The outcome for a given apartment would depend on its valuation method, tax rates, any phase-in and any exemptions in the final law. Comparing the department's market value with what similar units sell for gives you a starting point.
Is property tax reform the same as the pied-a-terre tax?
No. The pied-a-terre surcharge applies to certain high-value second homes and has its own rules and valuation base. Property tax reform would change how properties are valued and taxed in general.
When a bill appears, read it against your own Notice of Property Value before drawing conclusions.
Related insights
- NYC and Miami Real Estate Taxes
- NYC Tax Abatements: 421-a and J-51
- Will the Pied-a-Terre Tax Hurt Manhattan Luxury?
- Co-op vs Condo in NYC
Sources: The Real Deal Policy Pro (November 19, 2026); The East New York Times (November 17, 2026); NYC Department of Finance, Cooperative and Condominium Comparables and Determining Your Assessed Value; NYC Department of Finance, Fiscal Year 2027 tentative assessment roll release (January 2026); NYC Advisory Commission on Property Tax Reform, final report (December 29, 2021); Citizens Budget Commission testimony to the City Council Committee on Finance (November 15, 2022); Tax Equity Now NY LLC v City of New York, 2024 NY Slip Op 01498 (N.Y. March 19, 2024).