How Manhattan Buyers Check a Building, and the Lot Next Door, Before Signing

14 min read

On Wednesday, November 11, 2026, a three-story building on Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn fell into the excavation pit next door. At least eight people died, two of them children, and more than a dozen were injured. The Department of Buildings and the Brooklyn District Attorney are investigating, and the cause has not been determined.

Before you sign a Manhattan contract, you can review public city records for the building and for the lots beside it. Those records do not certify that a structure is safe, but they show reported conditions, enforcement history and nearby work, which gives you specific questions for your attorney and engineer. This guide covers what to pull, what the codes say about construction next door, and what to ask the board or managing agent.

For the full purchase process, from offer to closing, see our guide to buying an apartment in NYC.

At a glance

  • The Department of Buildings (DOB) publishes violations, permits and complaints for every building in the city through its Building Information System (BIS) and the DOB NOW Public Portal.
  • HPD Online lists housing code violations for residential buildings by class: A (non-hazardous), B (hazardous) and C (immediately hazardous).
  • Buildings taller than six stories need a facade inspection every five years under the Facade Inspection and Safety Program (FISP), often called Local Law 11. Cycle 10 runs from February 21, 2025 to February 20, 2030.
  • Contractors must notify DOB 24 to 48 hours before excavation starts. For deeper excavations near a neighbor, Building Code section 3304.3.2 generally requires written notice to the adjoining owners at least 10 days ahead.
  • DOB says open violations can prevent an owner from selling or refinancing, and that DOB violations appear in a title search.

What Has Been Reported So Far

The building that collapsed was a three-story, mixed-use property. It fell into a site next door where workers were excavating for a new building, after an older structure on that lot had been demolished. City housing records showed a long list of open violations at the collapsed building, according to CBS New York and NewsNation.

The Associated Press and CBS New York both reported that DOB issued a stop-work order at the neighboring site in March, after inspectors found demolition going on without adequate overhead protection. Inspectors found the work had resumed in April, and the order was lifted in May after the conditions were corrected. The developer had approval for a three-story building and had applied to amend it to nine stories, an amendment DOB had not approved, according to the AP and CBS.

Gothamist reported, as summarized by The Real Deal, that the approved excavation plans did not call for added bracing on the side facing the building that fell. The city has begun inspecting other job sites tied to the companies involved, and has said it is bringing in an independent engineering firm. None of this establishes a cause, and we draw no conclusion about one. The reporting does show which records belong in a buyer's review: violations, enforcement actions and approved plans.

Step One: Pull the Building's DOB Record

Start with the building's profile in BIS. Search by address and you will see the building's job filings, permits, complaints, violations and certificate of occupancy history. Newer filings and compliance records live in the DOB NOW Public Portal, so check both.

Two kinds of enforcement records show up there. DOB violations can concern missed compliance filings, such as annual boiler or elevator reports, as well as other code violations. OATH summonses are the more common enforcement tool, and DOB sorts them into Class 1 (immediately hazardous), Class 2 (major) and Class 3 (lesser). Unless OATH dismisses it, a summons stays open in BIS until DOB receives acceptable proof that the condition was corrected, even if the penalty has already been paid.

When you read the list, look at three things:

  • Status. Active or resolved. For resolved items, look at how long the correction took and whether the same condition keeps coming back.
  • Class. A Class 1 summons is for an immediately hazardous condition. Read its details and correction status before anything else.
  • Complaints. Read complaints about cracks, vibration or falling debris next to the inspections and violations, and keep in mind that a complaint is an allegation until an inspector confirms it.

Step Two: Check HPD and the Facade File

For residential buildings, HPD Online adds housing code violations, litigation, registration and vacate orders. HPD classes violations A, B and C by hazard, and lists Orders to Repair and Vacate Orders as class I. A rental building converted to condos, or a co-op with rental units, can carry HPD history that its sales listing does not mention.

For any building over six stories, find the latest FISP report. A qualified exterior wall inspector files it through DOB NOW: Safety, and each facade is classed Safe, SWARMP (safe with a repair and maintenance program) or Unsafe. An Unsafe facade means the owner must protect the public right away and make the repairs, which is often why a sidewalk shed appears. A SWARMP rating means the inspector found conditions that need repair within a time frame set in the report. In a co-op or condo, ask how those repairs will be paid for: from reserves, or through maintenance, common charges or an assessment. Cycle 10 filings are due on a staggered schedule set by the building's tax block, so ask which sub-cycle applies and whether the report has been filed and accepted.

Unless OATH dismisses it, a summons stays open in BIS until DOB receives acceptable proof that the condition was corrected, even if the penalty has already been paid.

Step Three: Look at the Lot Next Door

The Flatbush building fell into the site beside it. That makes neighboring construction a due diligence item in its own right.

DOB's Building on My Block tool shows zoning diagrams for new buildings and enlargements on your block, and the BIS and DOB NOW pages for the neighboring addresses show demolition, new building and foundation permits. The After Hours Variance Map shows whether a nearby site has permission to work at night or on weekends. If an adjacent lot is empty, recently demolished or fenced, look it up.

The Building Code puts specific duties on whoever digs next door:

  • Notice to DOB. Contractors must notify the department 24 to 48 hours before excavation, rock blasting or rock chipping begins.
  • Notice to neighbors. Under Building Code section 3304.3.2, an excavation deeper than 10 feet anywhere on a site, or 5 to 10 feet within 10 feet of an adjacent footing or foundation, requires written notice to the adjoining owners at least 10 days before work starts. The notice must describe the work, the timeframe and schedule, and give contact information for both the person causing the excavation and DOB. There is an exception when the excavation is set back from the neighbor's footing, foundation or property at a ratio of two horizontal to one vertical, measured from its deepest point.
  • Protection of your building. Section 3309.4 makes the person causing soil or foundation work responsible, at its own expense, for protecting adjoining structures, provided it is given a license to enter, inspect and do the necessary protective work. If that license is not given, the code shifts the protection duty to the adjoining owner. Section 3309.2 puts responsibility for granting the license on the adjoining owner and lets the party doing the construction petition a court under section 881 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law. Your attorney can explain how this applies to a specific access request.

DOB can audit excavation sites for shoring, depth, groundwater, movement monitoring and pre-construction surveys. Its own website adds that department monitoring "does not relieve engineers and contractors of their professional responsibilities." City audits do not replace the engineers' and contractors' own duties, so ask whether a building next to construction has retained its own engineer and signed an access agreement.

Questions for the Board, Managing Agent or Seller

  1. Open violations. Ask for a list of every open DOB violation, OATH summons and HPD violation, with the plan and timeline to clear each one. DOB says its violations and OATH summonses appear in a title search. Ask your attorney which other records need a separate check.
  2. The facade report. Ask for the most recent FISP report and its rating, the sub-cycle, and the cost and schedule of any SWARMP or Unsafe repairs. Ask whether those repairs are already funded from reserves or will need an assessment.
  3. Neighboring construction. Ask whether the building has received a 10-day excavation notice, signed a license or access agreement with a neighboring developer, or been asked for one. If so, ask who the building's engineer is and whether a pre-construction survey and movement monitoring are in place.
  4. Complaints and claims. Ask whether there are pending claims against a neighboring developer for cracks, water or settlement, and read the last two years of board minutes for the words crack, settlement, vibration and shoring.
  5. Townhouse buyers. If the townhouse sits next to a construction site, ask your attorney which adjoining-owner duties would apply to you and how existing access agreements or claims would be handled at closing. Ask the seller for any license agreements, survey reports or correspondence with neighboring sites, and have your engineer walk the party walls before contract.

None of this replaces your real estate attorney or a structural engineer, who should read the records with you. Reading them yourself first lets you ask sharper questions.

Buying a Manhattan co-op, condo or townhouse? We can help you pull the public building records for a property you are considering and line up the questions for the board. Message us on WhatsApp for a private, no-pressure conversation.

FAQ

How do I check a NYC building for open violations?

Search the address in the Department of Buildings' Building Information System (BIS) and in the DOB NOW Public Portal for DOB violations, OATH summonses, complaints and permits. For residential buildings, also search HPD Online for housing code violations, litigation and vacate orders. These are the city's public building records.

What is Local Law 11 or FISP?

The Facade Inspection and Safety Program requires owners of buildings taller than six stories to have exterior walls and appurtenances inspected every five years and to file a technical report with DOB. Facades are classed Safe, SWARMP or Unsafe. Cycle 10 runs from February 21, 2025 to February 20, 2030.

Can open violations stop a sale?

They can. DOB states that open violations can prevent an owner from selling or refinancing, that DOB violations appear in a property title search, and that it will not issue new or amended certificates of occupancy while DOB violations remain active.

Do developers have to notify neighbors before excavating in NYC?

For deeper excavations, generally yes. Building Code section 3304.3.2 requires written notice to adjoining owners at least 10 days before an excavation deeper than 10 feet, or 5 to 10 feet deep within 10 feet of an adjacent footing or foundation, unless the excavation is set back at a ratio of two horizontal to one vertical. Contractors must also notify DOB 24 to 48 hours before excavation begins.

Who is responsible for protecting a building next to an excavation?

Under Building Code section 3309.4, the person causing the soil or foundation work must protect adjoining structures at its own expense, provided it is given a license to enter, inspect and do the necessary protective work. If the license is not given, the duty shifts to the adjoining owner. Your attorney and engineer can review any access agreement your building signs.

The investigation into the Flatbush collapse is ongoing, and we will add confirmed findings to this guide when they are published.

Related insights

Sources: Associated Press (November 13, 2026); CBS New York; NewsNation; The New York Times (November 12, 2026); The Real Deal (November 14, 2026), citing Gothamist; NYC Department of Buildings (Find Building Data, Resolve a Summons or Violation, Excavation, FISP Filing Instructions, FISP Cycle 10 schedule); NYC Department of Housing Preservation and Development (Clear Violations, HPD Online); NYC Building Code sections 3304.3.2, 3309.2 and 3309.4.